Operating On a Stretcher Is a Safe Alternative to an Operating Room Table

Abstract

Christopher Garrett, James Eric Neal and Brett Lewellyn

Purpose: The primary purpose of this study was to compare intraoperative and post-operative complication rates for upper extremity surgical cases performed on a standard operating room (OR) table with similar cases done on a typical hospital stretcher. Secondary measures reviewed included surgical time, turnover time, total OR time, blood loss, tourniquet time, and postoperative complications.

Methods: Using our institution’s electronic medical record system, we reviewed 100 consecutive upper extremity cases performed on a stretcher as well as 100 consecutive upper extremity cases done on a standard OR table. All cases were performed by the same board certified, fellowship trained orthopaedic surgeon. The cases were performed between February of 2014 and May of 2016 at a level one trauma center and its associated outpatient surgical center. Basic univariate statistical analyses were performed, and the two groups were compared for primary and secondary outcome measures.

Results: The data showed no significant increase in intraoperative complication rates when operating on a standard hospital stretcher compared to operating on an OR table. There were a total of 6 postoperative complications in the stretcher group and a total of 11 complications in the OR table group. The most common postoperative complication seen in both cohorts was infection. There was one intraoperative complication in the OR table group and none in the stretcher group. With regard to total operating room time, surgical time, and delta time (overall OR room time minus surgical time which was used to calculate the turnover time), we found that the OR table group had shorter times in each category. The total OR time for the OR table group was a mean time of 105 minutes compared to 146 minutes seen in the stretcher group (p= 0.0002). Similarly, there was a shorter mean surgical time for surgeries done on an OR table (73 minutes) when compared to surgeries done on a stretcher (104 minutes) (p = 0.0026). Finally, the average turnover time (delta time) for the OR table group was 32 minutes while the average turnover time for the stretcher group was 42 minutes (p= 0.0002). The average tourniquet time for the OR table group was 36 minutes as compared to 41 in the stretcher group (p=0.467).

Conclusion: Operating on a typical hospital stretcher is a safe alternative to operating on a standard operating room table as there was no increased complication rate seen with surgeries performed on a stretcher compared to an OR table.

PDF