Dydrogesterone is Superior as Luteal Phase Support in selected Previously Failed In-Vitro Fertilisation and Embryo Transfer Patients

Abstract

Siddhartha Chatterjee, Bishista Bagchi and Arpan Chatterjee

Different forms of exogenous progesterone have been seen to play a very important role in endometrial maturity. Implantation failure appears to be a significant factor in Assisted reproductive technique (ART) procedures. Even a mature endometrium becomes non-receptive, preventing implantation or rejection of implanted embryo in early months of pregnancy. Hence natural micronized progesterone (NMP) and dydrogesterone have been used since decades to improve endometrial maturity and receptivity. The aim of this study was to investigate causes of failed implantation inspite of uneventful Grade I embryo transfer in ART procedure and the role of natural micronized progesterone (NMP) and dydrogesterone for endometrial maturation. 80 women aged range between 25-40 yr old who visited Department of Reproductive Medicine at Calcutta Fertility Mission, over a period of 24 months (January 2017 to December 2019), satisfying the inclusion criteria, were enrolled in this retrospective observational study. Endometrial aspirate histopathology was done during the secretory phase. They were treated with natural micronized progesterone (NMP) or oral dydrogesterone and results of endometrial changes, clinical pregnancy rate, live birth rate and miscarriage rate were statistically analysed. 26.25% and 29.6% of women were seen to have mid-secretory changes of the endometrium after being treated with NMP in one cycle and dydrogesterone in the subsequent cycle, respectively. 62.71% of women had shown early-secretory changes with dydrogesterone which was statistically significant compared to those treated with NMP (p value=0.006).8.5% of these women showed persistent non-secretory endometrium with either of these medications. The Clinical Pregnancy Rate (CPR) was 38.1% and 47% in the group of patients who were treated with NMP and dydrogesterone respectively. Though pregnancy rate was slightly higher in dydrogesterone group, it was not statistically significant (p value = 0.578). 28.5% and 41% women had live births and 9.5% and 5.8% of them had miscarriage in NMP and dydrogesterone group, respectively, though our data appears to be statistically not significant (p value –0.415) (p value – 0.679). In our study 26.25% women had mid-secretory endometrium after treatment with NMP. 29.6% and 62.71% of these women who had non-secretory or early secretory endometrial changes on treatment with intravaginal NMP, showed endometrial mid-secretory and early-secretory changes respectively, on treatment with dydrogesterone, which implies that oral dydrogesterone is superior to NMP when administered for endometrial maturation in selected patients. Clinical pregnancy rate, live birth rate or miscarriage rate were similar with either NMP or dydrogesterone.

PDF